Did I learn to be content? Or have I become complacent? Or worse yet, have I learned to be cynical.
The difference between contentment and complacency and cynicism can be hard to distinguish, they may look similar- though internally we likely we feel different, those close to us can likely feel the difference, and it will affect how we relate to others and to God and to life.
The biggest problem is we can fool ourselves easily into thinking we are practicing contentment. Others can’t really tell- and often their own experience/attitude can effect they way they see you too.
How can we know? What is the difference?
Biblically, contentment is something to be learned. So it is not natural. I’m not sure if that means cynicism or complacent is natural… or maybe we naturally try to control- and it is when we realize things are out of control, out of our control at least, we fall into cynicism or complacency or can choose contentment.
Generally when we speak of contentment we think of peace or happiness or stability. And we usually think of contentment as a general feeling of being at ease despite circumstances. Contentment is a feeling of happiness- though maybe not quite happy- even when circumstances are not ultimate desirable.
Contentment, Complaceny and Cynicsm and perhaps Control are all responses to life, to difficulties, to things not going as planned, to trouble. Or how we deal to life being out of control.
When our dreams don’t happen or we lose or life doesn’t go according to plan and we feel out of control
We may try to control things or become complacent. Or we learn to be content or we become cynical.
It is pretty common to describe old men as cynical – grumpy old men.
And it makes sense.
The more we live this life, the more things have gone wrong. The more evil we’ve seen. The more pain and hurt we have experienced. Of course we have become cynical. The world is broken.
People get sick, people die. Couple gets divorced, families get estranged, friendships fall apart. Marriage is not happily ever after, and all your wildest dreams did not come true.
Even if you worked and worked acheived all your goals, life feels meaningless.
As Solomon concludes in Ecclessastics- vanity, vanity all is vanity. It’s all chasing after the wind.
In the past year i have wondered if i had become complacent or just learned to be content in ministry and life. I have just dealt with it and kept moving. Was i content or had i just become complacent?
Then the other day, I was talking with a friend, and he used the word cynical to describe himself, and it kinda clicked with me – as i processed it with him, i began to see how cynicism has begun shaping my heart.
Contentment, Complacent, Cynicism are all ways we cope with disappointment in life.
Disappointment could be difficulty, but it is different. Difficulty is generally dissappointing, but not always the same either.
So we need to recognize we experience disappointment.
To guard against disappointment there are those who subscribe to the attitude – expectations are your enemy. High expectation = low yield. Low expectation = high satisfaction.
I suppose this is true. But does it really honor life? Is it living in truth? Or is denying part of ourselves?
I’m sure there is some health in having proper expectations. There is no need to set ourselves up for failure or disappointment. But if we continue to set the bar low- we’ll never get very high.
The addage is good however, if you don’t know what your expectations are. As i have led teams i have told them some say “no expectations, but i say know your expectations.”
IF we’re not aware of our expectations, we will be not just be disappointed- but blindsided by them.
We hold onto expectations and don’t realize it like – our family will be healthy, my kids will walk with God if i do the right things, God may not give me a million dollars but He will give enough so we don’t go broke, i will be treated fairly and kindly by others, if i obey God something good will go my way. If I read my Bible and pray and go to church- I will feel close to God.
I digress. Contentment, Complacent, Cynicism are all ways we cope with disappointment in life, when we reconginze we are not in control. So what is the difference?
Contentment focuses on the goodness of God. This turned out (bad/hard/difficult) – but God is still good.
Complacency focuses on our lack of control. This didn’t turn out the way we wanted, what can we do? Nothing.
Cynicism focuses on the broken world. This didn’t turn out the way we wanted, because this world is broken.
All three are actually true. This world is broken and we are not in control. But contentment in the midst of that only happens when we focus on the goodness of God.
Contentment still hopes, still loves.
Cynicsm slowly eats away at our joy and love to others.
Complacency just no longer cares. It is easier to not care anymore- rather than get hurt.
Cynicism and complacency are self-protective measures so we don’t feel hurt, don’t feel disappointed, don’t feel bad about ourselves, don’t feel sad. It masks our disappointment.
One of the easiest ways to see this is in singleness.
When i was in my mid & late 20s i learned to be content.
There would be some who said “You’ll find someone when you stop looking.”
In college my friend Karen said something like this- “you’ll find someone when you’re not expecting it”, and my friend Matt responded by saying “i’ll just sit here and not expect anything- should be any time now! Not expecting a thing, any time now”
This is not what i mean. Contentment in singleness is not merely stop looking – though it could be – it is contentment in the Lord- in His goodness, in His plan, in His love.
Another said to me – you’re not content, you still want to get married.
Yes, i did! If i didn’t want to get married still, i wouldn’t need to learn contentment. Being content had nothing to do with not caring anymore, but still desiring, but content in God.
I still prayed, still desired marriage, still considered girls and asked girls out- and i still hurt when they rejected me- but i had a peace, a joy, a contentment that came from God. i was able to be content in the relationships God did give me- my strong male friends who cared for me and knew me, my ministry i was able to have, the experiences i got and the initimate relationship with Christ – gave me contentment even as i still longed for marriage. I just gave it to God and trust my future to Him.
On the other hand, some endure singleness ( not that singleness is a disease or the worst thing in the world like It’s a wonderful life or your mom may have you believe – as the wise saying from Hitch says – you’re single, not sick”). (To this some like to blame the Church for making singleness to be the worst ever, but i think pop-culture is most guilty for this, not the church) – some endure singlness by becoming complacent or becoming cynical.
A complacent person stops caring about getting married and thus shuts others out. A cynical person becomes critical of others, cannot be happy for those who do get into relationships.
Another place we can explore this is in ministry.
Ministry is hard. We share the gopsel with many, and only some believe- others thinks about it, and others don’t and may even mock us. Then those who come to faith- some fall away, some grow slowly.
But in ministry we are taught not to find our identity in the fruit, to not measure success by numbers but faithfulness.
As a team leader, i wanted us to not just celebrate when things go well, but also when we take steps of faith.
But we don’t know how to do that well, and so instead of being content, we easily become complacent.
Complacency is super dangerous because we no longer care about God’s Kingdom, about people’s souls. We should hurt to some degree. We should weep when people turn from God. We should eagerly desire more people to come to Christ, we should ache when people experience injustice.
When we plan an outreach and not many show up- how do we respond?
If we are cynical, we didn’t think anything would happen anyway.
We likely gave lip-service to prayer. We likely were half-hearted in our efforts.
If we are complacent, we don’t care either way. People come – great? People don’t? No big deal.
We have become robots. We fall in line into a system and call it faithfulness, when it is just following mechanisms to say to ourselves we are doing our job. There is no vigor, no joy in us
If we are content, we long for people to come to Christ, we pray earnestly, we expend energy- but our identity, worth or joy is not based on the outcome. If people don’t show up- we are disappointed, we are sad and want to do things differently, but we are trusting in God’s goodness, we continue to seek God in prayer.
I’m not responding with – “We should have prayed more!” “We didn’t do ‘this or that’ enough.” Yes, we feel grief, but we but no we don’t indulge in shame. We give it to God and find our joy and peace Him- we recognize He is in control and He is good.
Sometimes we just need to cope. But what if we could move from coping to contentment?
As i look at my life, there are some things i have become complacent about, some i am rather cynical and perhaps a few where i have learned contentment.
If we are to walk with God for a life-time, and live in this fallen world and to pray diligently- we will face disappointment. How will we respond?
Will we grow old & cold? Will we look at youth and say they’re so naive? Will we stop dreaming, stop asking big? Will we become complacent in love, doing the bare minimum?
Or will be willing to dream, willing to Pray BIG, Love BIG, willing to face disappointment- and learn to be content.
We may stumble and fall many times along the way- but Jesus will always be there to pick us up.
We can learn contentment because we can trust in God’s goodness and wisdom and love- shown to us primarily in the Cross.
When Jesus died on the Cross, it was disappointing to His followers. They thought He was to be the Messiah to save them- but they walked disappointed and Jesus showed up – and showed them how the Messiah must suffer. Satan thought he had thwarted God. People felt despair- but God was working good.
As Joseph told his brothers – what you meant for evil, God purposed for good.
We don’t know what the good is, but we can trust God is working good. And so we can be content.
We won’t just be content, we’ll have to learn it, and we’ll have to choose it. But we don’t just act content.
Contentment is an act of faith, that requires faith. Contentment is fruit of faith.
We can learn to be content, when we learn to trust God. And He produces contentment in us
When we chose to meditate on the goodness of God and trust in God’s wisdom and sovereignty- we can learn contentment – a contentment produced not by human effort, but by God in us.